How Economies Grow by Doug Rothwell

200813Jul

Over the past several months, Detroit Renaissance has been analyzing why some economies grow and others don't to better understand how we move our region forward. It's an on-going process that will lead to the development of "Road to Renaissance 2.0" - our second generation regional economic transformation strategy - in the next year.

But suffice it to say, the findings we're reaching aren't rocket science. Here's a few nuggets to get started:

  • According to CEO Magazine, 9 of the 10 best states for business are in the sun belt and 7 of the 10 worst states (yes, Michigan is one of them) are in the "rust belt."
  • Not coincidentally, according to the Miliken Institute, 46 of the top 50 high growth cities are in the sun belt and 48 of the 50 worst performing cities (yes, Detroit is one of them) are in the "rust belt."

To add more fuel to the fire, consider this:

  • Accrding to Forbes Magazine, the top 10 states for private sector job growth over the past decade were ranked, on average, as having business cost environments that were more than twice as good than the ten worst performing states (yes, Michigan was among the bottom ten). 
  • Unfortunately, Michigan's relative state & local tax burden, according to the Tax Foundation, has actually increased since 1970.  In addition, Michigan ranked 40th and 41st respectively in the Forbes and Beacon Hill rankings on business costs and competitiveness.

Simply put, unless we fix the economic competitiveness of our state, we aren't going to see the pay-off we should from many of the innovative economic development initiatives underway throughout the state.

 - Doug 

Comments

David Olivencia:

I can't understand of the all types of businesses and incentives that we could proivde to stimulate the economy/aerotropolis that the best thing we could find is a horse race track.

I read the Detroit News article: http://www.detnews.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20080717/METRO/8071703...

What % of people who come to this are from out of state?
What % of people are just getting pulled from casino revenues?
How many jobs is this creating per incentives we gave?
What is the average salary of the people employed(grounds people, horse maintenance, operations,...)?

I think it makes better sense to give a company (i.e., like Google) who is already here incentives to set up a facility there. They make intellectual powerful stuff here, sell it around the world, and bring the money/jobs/new economy knowledge back here. Google has endless capacity for more jobs if the business grows where a horse track appears flat in its growth. 1000 Google jobs at 100K each has an annual $100 Million impact with stronger upside growth.

Help educate me on the opportunity costs of this deal versus other types of high growth businesses(google was only an example there are many other great biotech, alternate energy,high growth companies...).

P.S. We need to move faster on the aerotropolis!

Moving forward,

David Olivencia
http://www.linkedin.com/in/davidolivencia